Ministers have decided to withdraw an amendment concerning the intelligence services in the Hillsborough Law, following strong opposition from bereaved families and Members of Parliament.
Keir Starmer was at risk of facing a revolt as the significant bill, aimed at preventing future government cover-ups and named after the tragic events of 1989, is set to be discussed in the House of Commons on Monday. The proposed legislation includes the introduction of a “duty of candour” legal requirement for public officials to act truthfully or face potential criminal consequences.
An amendment by the government intended to incorporate intelligence operatives from MI5 and MI6 into the scope of the law, with their disclosures subject to approval by their superiors, was met with criticism from campaigners and grieving families. Concerns were raised that this provision would grant the security service leaders the authority to decide whether or not to reveal information. Discussions between stakeholders and the government took place over the weekend.
It has been revealed that the amendment will not be put forward on Monday, with the government planning to collaborate with families to propose adjustments when the bill moves to the House of Lords.
Keir Starmer, who has engaged with the affected families on multiple occasions, received support from Margaret Aspinall, a prominent figure connected to the Hillsborough disaster. Starmer reassured the families that the integrity of the legislation would not be compromised.
A government spokesperson emphasized the significance of the legislation in rectifying past injustices and ensuring transparency in government operations. The spokesperson highlighted the need for officials to be accountable and forthcoming in times of error, without compromising national security.
Over the weekend, the mayors of Liverpool and Manchester urged the Prime Minister to retract an amendment to the Hillsborough Law that they believe provides overly broad exemptions for intelligence services. The mayors emphasized the importance of collaborating with families and advocacy groups to find a mutually agreeable solution.
Following the government’s decision to withdraw the contentious amendment, there has been a positive response from lawmakers and campaigners, indicating a willingness to find a resolution that satisfies all parties.
Culture Secretary Ms. Nandy affirmed that the security services will not be exempt from the “duty of candour” requirement for public officials. She stressed the need to avoid situations like the Manchester Arena inquiry, where information was withheld, leading to inaccurate portrayals. Ms. Nandy expressed confidence in resolving the issue through ongoing discussions.